New for 2012 News21 Open to All Schools

Key Findings

Motor vehicle accidents claim more lives than any other kind of transportation accident, yet no federal system exists for enforcing safety standards. That’s left up to states, which have been both inconsistent and resistant.
 
Related stories:
In No Shape to Drive
One Doctor’s Solution
Escaping Oversight
Reincarnated Carrier
Black Boxes
Texting while Driving
School Bus Crash
Stopping Highway Accidents
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4

After Texas repealed its universal helmet law in 1997, helmet use fell dramatically while deaths rose, according to Bill Gossard, NTSB safety advocate specialist. A study published in the Southern Medical Journal this year concluded that in just two years helmet use in Texas dropped from 77 percent to 36 percent and motorcycle deaths rose 30 percent.

In Florida, a universal helmet law was partially repealed in 2000. Now motorcyclists 21 and older can ride helmet-free as long as they are insured. Florida also is one of the states with the most motorcycle-related deaths: 3,813 between 2000 and 2008.

The numbers do not convince the American Motorcycle Association, which has lobbied for decades against helmet laws for adults.

“The difficulty with numbers going up and down is it is very difficult to identify the variables that contribute to the statistics,” association spokesman Peter terHorst said. “Simply jumping to the conclusion that forcing everyone to wear a helmet will reduce fatalities is a short-sighted approach.”

The motorcycle association isn’t against helmets, terHorst added. It’s against the notion that government should tell adults what to do when it comes to personal safety. Helmet laws also give law enforcement carte blanche to pull people over, and they’re too expensive, he said. A helmet of the sort endorsed by the U.S. Department of Transportation carries an average price tag of between $100 and $300.

Currently, three states, Illinois, Iowa and New Hampshire, do not have any kind of motorcycle helmet law.

New Hampshire had a law for 10 years, but in 1977, the Legislature decided it should apply only to riders 18 and older. Then in 1995, lawmakers repealed the law altogether.

Iowa legislators have proposed two laws to require helmets for motorcyclists under the age of 18, but both bills died for lack of interest, said Phil McCormick, state coordinator for A Brotherhood Aimed Toward Education of Iowa, a nonprofit organization that lobbies for motorcyclist rights.

Some safety advocates say states should be forced to implement safety regulations such as helmet laws. But that, said the NTSB’s Blackistone, is not territory the safety board wants to enter.

“We try to stay out of the philosophical,” he said. “We are not prescriptive; we cannot mandate implementation.”

News21 reporter Aarti Shahani contributed to this report.

Sept. 26, 2010

Pages: 1 2 3 4

One Response to “States Resist Highway Safety Measures”

  1. John Lin says:

    Did anyone even get a purely uninvolved perspective of the data? Was anyone besides a federal agency that is funded based upon its size, and two special interest groups consulted?

    The federal government coerced Montana to adopt speed limits on its interstates. You have the data. You made a little interactive map. Please point out the lives saved.

    Seatbelts and helmets save lives. However, having seen both those that wore helmets and those not admitted to a level 1 trauma center, I think one could make a legitimate argument that it is better NOT to wear one. When doctors make mistakes, they have Mortality AND Morbidity reviews. People make choices that get them killed all the time. Nicotine is a bigger killer than neglecting seatbelts. This should be contrasted with alcohol consumption, in which one person’s irresponsibility kills someone ELSE. Yet, this article focused on public policy for enforcing an issue of PERSONAL responsibility.

    The media’s responsibility is to educate the public. Please educate them as to how many of those fatalities are interstate accidents versus how many are people running redlights in intersections and running over kids in school zones. A blogger can summarize the synopsis of a NHTSA report. A journalist should go deeper.

Share:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS

Tim Crain of Roodhouse, Ill., waits for his truck to be inspected near Flagstaff, Ariz., in June. (Photo by AJ Maclean/News21)

A tour bus rolled over in January of 2008 in Victoria, Texas, killing 47. The company that owned the bus had been ordered out of service for safety violations. (NTSB Photo)